
With films such as 'I Am Legend,' 'The Road' and more recently '2012' captivating audiences, the Hughes brothers picked the end-of-the-world genre to seal their comeback after nearly a decade of hiding.
Starring Denzel Washington, Gary Oldman, Mila Kunis and Jennifer Beales, 'The Book of Eli' is an action-thriller that will have moviegoers wondering why they spent their hard-earned money on yet another post-apocalyptic fantasy
We are first introduced to Washington's character, Eli, who is referred to as Walker because he's been walking the Earth for the last 30 years after the final war left the world in dust and despair. With a backpack containing a Bible, a machete and a shotgun, Eli is able to survive on his own by killing what animal he finds for nourishment. Wearing dark shades to protect his eyes from the blinding sun, he's heading West, where he believes life can be restored.
As he stops by a town to collect water and materials for his long journey, Eli runs into the local kingpin named Carnegie (Oldman), who's been dispatching every degenerate he can find to search for a book that he feels can fuel his power and influence. With his blind girlfriend, Claudia (Beales), reluctantly serving his needs, Carnegie sends her daughter Solara (Kunis) to spy on Eli.
When Solara returns and accidentally reports to Carnegie that Eli has the Bible he's been seeking, the last one on Earth, all hell breaks loose as the two men play a game of cat and mouse, with Solora choosing to stick with Eli for safety. Not too pleased with Solora's choice is Carnegie's henchman Redridge (Ray Stevenson), who wants Solora for himself.
As Eli and Solora walk the Earth together, they come upon what looks like an abandoned house. When the occupants inside turn out to be reluctant allies, the last stand between Eli and Carnegie turns into the O.K. Corral, as the Bible holds the key to the future.
The problem with the film, besides the religious overtones, is the lack of continuity. From the guys who brought us 'Menace II Society' and 'Dead Presidents,' the Hughes brothers have too many scenes with too few explanations. It's never clear, for example, how Eli is able to walk around with an M3 player if the war occurred nearly three decades ago?
Although Washington is credible in his larger-than-life character, with superhero-like skills that allow him to fend off more than five men at a time, not much is known about him or any of the characters.
Oldman, who plays Commissioner Gordon in the Batman films, is back to playing a mercenary villain with some gusto. While it's not the same intensity he displayed in 'Air Force One' or 'The Professional,' it would have been fun just to hear him say, "Bring me everyone," just once.
Considering it's the end of the world, it's just unbelievable to see Solara walking around town unafraid of anyone and wearing rags that seem to come from Banana Republic.
Not all is lost, though. There is a twist to the film. Unfortunately, though, it can't make up for a big story that falls way short.


Comments: (11)
Add a comment
By: nyc girl on 1/15/2010 4:02PM
The commentor is expecting more than they could ever give to a film. I's easy to sit back and critisize a film and not think about the message. Yet when the film goes to DVD, they want to add it to their collection or stay home and watch it on tv, then call it a classic/cult film. Anyone who does not feel anything from The Book of Eli is heartless, similar to those people who tremble and shake in the film (having no emotions for anyone else in life) Five stars to the Hughes Brothers for getting down like that and of course, to Denzel for maintaining his style and craft.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: AKByes on 1/15/2010 8:36PM
I totally agree with you NYC girl..this Movie was to me prophetic....I was so eterntained and exhorted at the same time...I am sooooo lovin' this movie...And Denzel can walk for me any day! He da bomb! Thanks to the producers for having the guts to go THERE!
Report This
By: Chicki Brown on 1/16/2010 7:47AM
Why are "religious overtones" a problem?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: DUKE from Decatur,Ga. on 1/16/2010 6:09PM
Well, Mr Morales is a film critic and he's doing his job. I have seen several post world war 3 movies including(iam legend)will smith and (a.d.babaylon) van diesel. they have the same premise get somebody or something to someone and save the rest of the world. Look, it's entertaining so enjoy it and let d.washington & h. brothers make some money!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: dem777l on 1/17/2010 10:05AM
I saw the "Book of Eli" with my 3 sons,ages l4,l6,and l7.(Yes, they still go to the movies with mom...lol)This movie had them engaged from begining to end...It opened them up to so much dialogue about the Bible and end times,I was delighted for that alone.
The story is fiction but the subject is real to me...KUDOS to the HUGHES BROS. AND MR. D.W. (he never disappoints his fans with his choice of roles) Oh, Yeah at the end of the movie the theater burst into appalause...that's rare!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Black Moses on 1/17/2010 10:13AM
The bible is one of the major tools of the system of white supremacy. It doesn't change because you have a Denzel vice a charleston heston. Blacks have too much jesus and too much allah. We are constantly spitting on our Ancestor's by promoting the invader's religious beliefs.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: 2peace on 1/18/2010 11:26AM
Black Moses,
In case you didn't know, the Bible was written by people who were from the Middle East, not Europeans. So tired of black folks who call it a 'white-man's religion' when we know the Bible was revealed to and through people from the East.
One more thing BM: you talk about "spitting on our Ancestor's by promoting the invader's religious beliefs."? Well...aren't YOU spitting on the ancestor's who DID BELIEVE in the Bible? Ancestor's who looked to Jesus while enduring the slavemaster's whip?
Just asking...
Report This
By: Black Moses on 1/17/2010 6:37PM
2peace: My Ancestors were not praying to no jesus in the bowels of those slaves ships and my Ancestors whom embrace this great white myth (my dear grandmother included) were wrong, but I don't throw the baby out with the bath water. Christanity is what it is, "white supremacy. We were not praying to no jesus, carrying around crosses, talking about a virgin birth, the dead arises, etc., before the white man came to the shores of ancient african. Like Dr. John H. Clarke stated, "if you are going to embrace a religion, at least embrace one that hadn't been so brutal to you." Where our Ancestors are mostly likely from (West Africa) is not the middle east; we are older than this myth.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Marche on 1/18/2010 1:09PM
i agree with nyc girl...i went to go see this movie last night and i loved it...it had that thing to grab u nd catch ur attention nd it had that message to make it a memorable movie.i think its funny how u pick out that one part with the mp3 player nd that makes it unclear...please give me a break..this will be a movie to remember this is one of the few movies that has a purpose nd we should cherish it
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: MDF on 1/20/2010 3:07PM
The Book of Eli was GRAAND!!!!!!! I loved it.....the movie was set in the FUTURE....30 years into THE FUTURE....so I can see where he would have had an OLD MP3 player...duh.....Solara clothes were questionable....but the rest of it was GREAT.....made me want to be even more thankful! Wonderful message......the movie did not suck nearly as much as this dumb review!!!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This