
With films such as 'I Am Legend,' 'The Road' and more recently '2012' captivating audiences, the Hughes brothers picked the end-of-the-world genre to seal their comeback after nearly a decade of hiding.
Starring Denzel Washington, Gary Oldman, Mila Kunis and Jennifer Beales, 'The Book of Eli' is an action-thriller that will have moviegoers wondering why they spent their hard-earned money on yet another post-apocalyptic fantasy
We are first introduced to Washington's character, Eli, who is referred to as Walker because he's been walking the Earth for the last 30 years after the final war left the world in dust and despair. With a backpack containing a Bible, a machete and a shotgun, Eli is able to survive on his own by killing what animal he finds for nourishment. Wearing dark shades to protect his eyes from the blinding sun, he's heading West, where he believes life can be restored.
As he stops by a town to collect water and materials for his long journey, Eli runs into the local kingpin named Carnegie (Oldman), who's been dispatching every degenerate he can find to search for a book that he feels can fuel his power and influence. With his blind girlfriend, Claudia (Beales), reluctantly serving his needs, Carnegie sends her daughter Solara (Kunis) to spy on Eli.
When Solara returns and accidentally reports to Carnegie that Eli has the Bible he's been seeking, the last one on Earth, all hell breaks loose as the two men play a game of cat and mouse, with Solora choosing to stick with Eli for safety. Not too pleased with Solora's choice is Carnegie's henchman Redridge (Ray Stevenson), who wants Solora for himself.
As Eli and Solora walk the Earth together, they come upon what looks like an abandoned house. When the occupants inside turn out to be reluctant allies, the last stand between Eli and Carnegie turns into the O.K. Corral, as the Bible holds the key to the future.
The problem with the film, besides the religious overtones, is the lack of continuity. From the guys who brought us 'Menace II Society' and 'Dead Presidents,' the Hughes brothers have too many scenes with too few explanations. It's never clear, for example, how Eli is able to walk around with an M3 player if the war occurred nearly three decades ago?
Although Washington is credible in his larger-than-life character, with superhero-like skills that allow him to fend off more than five men at a time, not much is known about him or any of the characters.
Oldman, who plays Commissioner Gordon in the Batman films, is back to playing a mercenary villain with some gusto. While it's not the same intensity he displayed in 'Air Force One' or 'The Professional,' it would have been fun just to hear him say, "Bring me everyone," just once.
Considering it's the end of the world, it's just unbelievable to see Solara walking around town unafraid of anyone and wearing rags that seem to come from Banana Republic.
Not all is lost, though. There is a twist to the film. Unfortunately, though, it can't make up for a big story that falls way short.


Comments: (11)
Add a comment
By: Marc M on 2/17/2010 3:43AM
I saw it the other day. It was ok. But there were a few things that just didn't make sense or were unlogical. To begin with, the open scene is in a dark forest during a ash fall. A black gasmasked and hazmat suited individual. Whom we assume is the tituled Character. Is using a dead human body to lure in a domestic cat into his ambush. Which he kills with a wooden bow and what look to be some homemade arrow. Then we next see him walking along a highway with a backpack, no bow or arrows in site. An it's not like they could be easily concealed, like he does his machete. Then more then halfway thru the movie. The bow and homemade arrows just seem to magically appear. Which to me seems like a big continuity error.
Also the fallout at the beginning is also confusing. Because the story is suppose to be set 30 years after the "Flash" event happen.
An of course I have this same problem with "The Road"! Which is traveling during day, by walking right on the highway. Then each night Eli makes a fire that can be seen for miles. An falls a sleep listening to his favorite tunes on his Ipod. In reality if that was the case. One would had their throat slit in no time.
Realistically, the best way would be to travel by night and lay up somewhere out of sight of the highway during the day. An for the shortest time possible, building a small smokeless fire to boil water and cook with, near dawn. When there is less likelyhood that anyone in the traveler attacking business, to already being up and on the prowl. Those types are notoriously late sleepers.
Also to have a still functioning Ipod going on 30 years is a little unrealistic. An to be so careless to leave it running all night, wasting it's charge would be just stupid.
There are a few other little things, like the dogs and cats wandering around the town. They would of been in someones stewpots long ago. An the old cannibal couple lasting that long with a still intact house. An that every single Bible was burnt right after the "Flash" as I mentioned before, seems far fetched. I mean really,how many churches, let alone hotel rooms are there in your average
town. Bibles applenty.
Then again those Bibles do make some fine fire starting material! I'm sure by
then all the X-tians will have been taken up in the Rapture. so I guess they
would have no more need of them.They did the same thing to Disco Records in the late 70's, an you can still see many of those around!:) Well I guess I'll quit nitpicking.
Reply to this Comment | Report This